COVID-19 UPDATE: We are open! Our team is working and offering consultations via phone, e-mail, and video conferencing. Learn More
Call For Your Free Consultation (919) 335-7005

$2.25 Million Settlement in Pavement Drop-Off Crash

Plaintiffs have settled an accident claim in which an 85-year-old woman was killed and her 87-year-old husband was injured for $2.25 million.

The claim was unusual in that it involved both a legally impaired defendant driver and a claim against a paving company that was repaving the road at the time.

The accident occurred as the elderly couple was returning to their home in Eastern North Carolina following a doctor’s appointment. The two-lane road they were traveling on was in the process of being repaved, it was unlit, and it was raining. A pickup truck in the oncoming lane, driven by a 28-year-old man who had been drinking and was returning from hunting, went off the road, overcorrected, and came into the couple’s lane, causing a collision. The elderly woman died at the scene; her husband suffered orthopedic injuries and a closed head injury.

The driver of the pickup was never charged with DWI. Instead, the investigating trooper testified that during the more than one hour he spent in the driver’s presence, the trooper did not smell any odor of alcohol, the driver was coherent and showed no signs of having consumed alcohol and so the trooper did not perform a field sobriety test. The trooper brought the pickup driver to the hospital, where his blood was taken. Only after the pickup driver already had pleaded guilty to careless and reckless driving did his blood alcohol test come back showing a .08 reading, taken two hours after the wreck.

After settling with the driver for his policy limits, plaintiff sued the paving company for its role in the wreck. The pickup driver said it was very difficult to see that night because it was raining and there was no edge line on the road yet. He said when he went off the road, there was a substantial drop-off, causing him to lose control of his truck.

The paving company blamed the drunk driver entirely for the wreck, putting plaintiffs in the position of downplaying the pickup driver’s alcohol consumption and pointing to the lack of indications that he was surstantially impaired.

The night of the wreck, the trooper measured an 8-inch drop-off from the pavement to the shoulder of the road. Plaintiff alleged that N.C. Department of Transportation rules, which applied to the paving project, required that any drop-off larger than two inches had to be backfilled every night. The paving company argued that the DOT rule applied only to widening projects, and did not apply to resurfacing projects, which had a two-week window for backfill.

DOT witnesses were inconsistent in their testimony about the rule, although more endorsed the two-week window. Plaintiffs argued that regardless of the DOT rule, the paving company had created a dangerous condition by allowing an 8-inch drop-off to remain in place for some days. Plaintiffs’ accident reconstructionist testified that research showed that the driver of virtually any vehicle that experiences an 8-inch drop-off will lose control if they attempt to bring the vehicle back on the road.

The case settled shortly before trial. Since the start of the case, DOT has amended its rule, requiring that drop offs be fixed within 72 hours.

Settlement Report

  • Inner Circle of Advocates
    This is a rare and exclusive legal honor limited to the top 100 attorneys in the US, and we are proud to have John Edwards and David Kirby included.
  • Best Lawyers In America
    Four Edwards Kirby Attorneys Named to The Best Lawyers in America.
  • U.S. News Best Law Firm
    We are proud to be included in this prestigious list of law firms, selected for both quality of practice and extent of legal experience and skill.
  • SuperLawyers
    This rating service honors attorneys who have achieved a high level of professional achievement and peer recognition. Selected attorneys are included in Super Lawyers® magazine’s list.
  • AV Preeminent
    This highly prestigious honor is reserved for attorneys who are nominated by both clients and peers in a range of categories, including Quality of Service, Legal Experience, and more.
  • American Board of Trial Advocates
    This prestigious organization aims to continuously build upon a foundation of legal ethics and high technical standards for civil trial attorneys. We are proud to have membership in the American Board of Trial Advocates.
  • Legal Elite
    This honor, awarded by Business North Carolina magazine, recognizes the state’s top business and employment lawyers, as selected by their peers in a statewide ballot.
  • American College of Trial Lawyers
    Fellowship in the American College of Trial Lawyers is extended only to the top 1% of attorneys in a given state or providence. Our firm is proud to have members of this prestigious North American organization.
  • International Society of Barristers
    The International Society of Barristers aims to encourage fellowship, ethics, and advocacy excellence. We are proud to have attorneys who are Fellows of the Society, committed to the highest level of integrity and civility.
  • The National Trial Lawyers Top 100
    Attorney John Edwards has been included in this invitation only group of the premier trial lawyers in each state.
  • National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40
    Attorneys Cate Edwards, Winston Kirby and Mary Kathryn Kurth were named "Top 40 Under 40" by the National Trial Lawyers.
  • Lawyers of Distinction
    Attorney Cate Edwards has been selected for this prestigious award after undergoing a stringent evaluation process based on peer recognition, past results, and reputation. Only the top 10% of attorneys in each state are selected to the final list.