Understanding At-Fault Accidents in North Carolina
Jul 09, 2025
When an accident occurs, determining who is at fault is a crucial part of the insurance and legal process. Being “at fault” means that a driver is considered legally responsible for causing the collision, either through negligence, recklessness, or a traffic violation.
Understanding fault is essential because it influences how damages are paid, how claims are processed, and whether a driver may face legal consequences or increased insurance premiums. At Edwards Kirby, we have extensive experience navigating the complex legal landscape of car accidents in North Carolina–including helping clients understand what is an at fault accident and how to protect their rights.
What Are At-Fault Accidents?
At-fault accidents are traffic incidents in which one or more drivers are deemed legally responsible for causing the crash. Responsibility is typically determined by law enforcement officers, insurance adjusters, or the courts, based on evidence such as witness statements, traffic camera footage, and police reports.
Understanding what is an at fault accident is essential for drivers in North Carolina, where the legal financial consequences can be significant. These include higher insurance premiums, out-of-pocket expenses (especially if the driver is underinsured), and potential civil liability if the other party decides to sue for damages.
What is The Difference Between No-Fault and At-Fault Accidents?
In an at-fault accident system, the driver who caused the accident is responsible for the resulting damages. Their insurance provider pays for repairs, medical bills, and other losses experienced by the non-fault party, up to the limits of the policy.
By contrast, no-fault insurance systems require each driver’s insurance to cover their own medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of who caused the accident. This system is designed to reduce legal disputes and speed up claims processing, but it typically does not cover vehicle repairs or allow for lawsuits unless injuries are severe.
Legal Responsibilities in At-Fault Accidents in North Carolina
In North Carolina, drivers found at fault in a car accident face specific legal and financial responsibilities under the state’s “contributory negligence” system. This legal standard is one of the strictest in the U.S.—if the other party is found to be even 1% at fault, they may be barred from recovering any compensation. As a result, being found fully at fault in an accident carries significant consequences.
An at-fault driver in North Carolina may be held responsible for:
- Property Damage: Paying for repairs or replacement of the other party’s vehicle and any other damaged property.
- Medical Expenses: Covering the costs of injuries suffered by other parties involved in the crash.
- Legal Liability: Facing potential civil lawsuits if the injured party sues for damages beyond what insurance covers.
- Insurance Ramifications: Increased premiums and possible policy non-renewal, depending on the severity of the incident and the driver’s history.
- Traffic Citations or Criminal Charges: If the accident involved reckless driving, DUI, or other violations, the driver could also face criminal penalties.
Determining Fault in Accidents
Determining fault in a car accident is a critical step in resolving insurance claims and legal disputes. The process typically involves an investigation by law enforcement, insurance adjusters, or sometimes legal professionals. Several tools and sources of evidence are used to establish who was responsible for the crash.
Key elements in determining fault in an accident include:
- Police Reports: Officers responding to the scene often document the circumstances, statements from drivers and witnesses, and any citations issued. Their report may contain an opinion on fault.
- Witness Statements: Third-party accounts can provide an unbiased view of what happened, especially in disputes over traffic signal compliance or right-of-way.
- Photographic or Video Evidence: Dashcams, traffic cameras, and cellphone photos can capture key moments before and during the accident.
- Vehicle Damage and Accident Reconstruction: The location and extent of damage on each vehicle help determine the angle and force of impact, which can reveal how the collision occurred.
- Driver Statements and Behavior: Admissions of fault, distracted driving (e.g., texting), or impaired behavior may weigh heavily in fault determination.
Ultimately, insurance companies make their own assessments, which may or may not align with the police report. In contentious cases, attorneys or courts may be involved to make a final determination.
Comparative and Contributory Negligence in North Carolina
North Carolina follows the contributory negligence rule. Under this much stricter standard, if a driver is found even slightly at fault—just 1%—they are barred from recovering any damages from the other party. This makes establishing complete lack of fault critical for any driver seeking compensation in the state.
Because of this rigid rule, many at-fault claims in North Carolina can become highly contested, and legal counsel is often necessary to navigate the process.
Recovering Damages in At-Fault Accidents
After an at-fault accident, financial recovery and responsibility become key concerns for all parties involved. While the at-fault driver is typically responsible for compensating the injured party, those affected may seek damages through insurance claims, personal injury lawsuits, or additional legal avenues. Recovery can include compensation for medical expenses, property damage, lost wages, and other losses, depending on the severity and circumstances of the accident.
In most at-fault accidents, the responsible driver’s liability insurance is expected to cover the resulting damages. This typically includes:
- Medical expenses for injured parties, including emergency care, hospital bills, and rehabilitation costs.
- Property damage to vehicles and other personal property affected in the crash.
- Lost wages if the injured party is unable to work due to their injuries.
- Pain and suffering or other noneconomic damages, in certain cases.
Do You Have a Car Accident Claim in North Carolina?
At-fault drivers carry significant responsibilities, from covering property damage and medical bills through their insurance to facing potential lawsuits. Conversely, injured parties need to be aware of how fault is determined and what legal avenues may be available for recovering damages.
If you’re wondering what is an at fault accident and how it might impact your ability to seek compensation, our attorneys are here to provide clear guidance. Whether you were partially involved or fully blameless—our attorneys can help you evaluate your rights, build a strong case, and pursue the compensation you deserve. At Edwards Kirby, we have extensive experience assisting clients with car accident claims in North Carolina.
Don’t let a misunderstanding of state laws or insurance limitations jeopardize your recovery. Contact Edwards Kirby today for a free consultation and trusted legal support.
Related Posts

We’re Here to Help
Call 919-780-5400 or fill out our online form to request a free consultation. You won’t pay unless we win!